Nasrollah Mahboobi Soofiani, Fatemeh Shir-Mohammad, Javad Pour-Reza,
Volume 2, Issue 1 (4-1998)
Abstract
A 46-day feeding trial was conducted with rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) to examine the effects of partial substitution of plant protein sources with fish meal in diets. Three different sources of plant protein including soybean, sunflower and cottonseed meals were substituted by fish meal at four levels of 10, 20, 30 and 40 percentages. Each diet was assigned to triplicate groups of fish in a completely randomized design as a 3×4 factorial arrangement, with a control diet. Seven hundred and eighty fish were used in this trial. Twenty fish were randomly assigned to each of 39 pens and were acclimated in these pens to the experimental conditions two weeks before treatments began. This substitution caused no significant differences in all the criteria measured with control diet. Fish fed diets of 30 and 40 percent soybean meal substitution showed greater weight gain and better growth performance, lower FCR and higher PER values in comparison with the fish receiving other diets, although the differences were not significant. Irrespective of substitution levels, comparison of fish fed by three different sources of plant protein in their diets showed that the fish fed diet containing sunflower meal had significantly (p<0.0l) lower final mean weight and growth performance, higher FCR and lower PER than the fish receiving soybean and cottonseed meal diets. Relative liver weight of fish receiving soybean meal diets was significantly (p<0.0l) higher than those fed with cottonseed meal diets, but the difference was not significant when compared with the fish fed with the sunflower meal diets. Partial replacement of cottonseed meal resulted in a higher energy availability to fish and also better performance of fish. However, diets containing soybean meal showed not much effects on performance of rainbow trout. These results indicate that cottonseed and soybean meals can be recommended as a suitable and fish meal-sparing ingredient in diets for rainbow trout.
M. Shivazad, H. Janmohamadi,
Volume 6, Issue 1 (4-2002)
Abstract
A Complete Randomized Block design was used to study the total protein efficiency (TPE) in Iranian Kilka and Peruvian Anchovy fish meals. Six isoenergetic (3200 kcal ME/kg) and isonitrogenous (18.5% CP) diets based on corn with six samples of fish meal (No. 1, 5, 6 steam processed, 2, 4 flame processed Kilka fish meal and No. 3 Peruvian Anchovy fish meal) were formulated and fed to Lohman male chicks from 7 to 42 days of age. Feed consumption and weight gain were measured weekly. Total protein efficiency and feed conversion (FC) were calculated and statistically analyzed.
The highest TPE values in fish meals obtained over the period of 7-28 days and significantly differed (P< 5%) among Kilka and Peruvian fish meals. With the exception of sample No. 5, the highest values of TPE obtained in the case of steam processed and the lowest obtained the case of flame processed Kilka fish meals. The TPE value of Peruvian fish meal was approximately equal to the average of the two types of processed Kilka fish meals. The orthogonal and nonorthogonal comparison of TPE and feed conversion (FC) in Kilka fish meals, regardless of the type of processing, with the same values in Peruvian Anchovy fish meal did not show any significant differences (P> 5%). With the exception of sample No. 5, the highest final weight of chicks obtained with steam processed Kilka fish meal. In general, TPE values in Kilka fish meals were variable when compared to Peruvian fish meal and TPE of steam processed Kilka fish meal was better.
S. A. Hadj Heidari, Gh. Ghorbani, M. Alikhani,
Volume 9, Issue 2 (7-2005)
Abstract
To compare the relative value of the fish meal and the cottonseed meal in highly fermentable diets (40% forage and 60% concentrate with), eight cows were assigned randomly to diets with 0, 1.5, 3 and 4.5 percent of the fish meal. In the first experiment, the degradability of dry matter and crude protein of the fish meal, the cottonseed meal and concentrate in diets was estimated with different incubation times (0, 4, 8, 12 and 24 h) with fistulated Ghezel sheep fed at maintenance level. The effective degradability of dry matter and the crude protein of fish meal was significantly lower than cottonseed meal (p<0.05). In different concentrates, there was no significant difference in effective degradability of dry matter but with the increase of fish meal the effective degradability of crude protein decreased significantly. In the second experiment, the eight multiparous Holstein cows with the similar milk production (25.37 ± 0.85) were examined in a replicated 4 × 4 Latin square design with the 21-day period. There were no significant differences between the treatments in digestibility of OM, OM and CP, the dry matter intake, 3.2 % FCM, milk fat (%), milk lactose (%), milk total solid (%), and the yield of the milk fat, feed efficiency and body weights. Diets containing fish meal, compared to the control group, significantly higher milk production, milk protein (%), the yield of milk protein and lactose (p < 0.1), but the different levels of fish meal had no significant effect on these factors. The urea pH decreased significantly with the increase of the fish meal but rumen pH and fecal pH were unaffected. The results of the experiment indicated that diets with the 1.5 or 3% fish meal in cows with less than 30 kg milk is recommended.
